| metric | value | source |
|---|---|---|
| overall maturity | 453‰ across 21 domains · 0 at S-class | knowledge/store/ecomat via em_rollup_store (same call as /compare/maturity) |
| validation | triangulated 9 · single-src 5 · dangling 0 · conflicts 0 | two independent witnesses per grade; conservative MIN consensus |
| live autonomy | 328‰ | knowledge/status/autonomy_meter.log |
| total | done | open | external | detail |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 199 | 53 | 144 | 2 | CPM board: critical path, float, ready/blocked |
| w | open big rocks (weight ≥ 8) |
|---|---|
| 8 | F208 · autonomous backlog feeder |
| 8 | F214 · seat lease orphan reap |
| 8 | F217 · loop R3 actlog + workflow miner |
| 8 | F218 · loop R4 role daemons zero-claude |
| 8 | F101a · GPU provision + deploy |
| 8 | F101b · first sovereign submit |
| 8 | F101c · C0 FP32 GEMM |
| 8 | F101d · C1 tensor-core BF16 |
| meter | count | source |
|---|---|---|
| supervised fleet daemons | 38 | daemons.reg rows |
| MCP tools GREEN | 137 | tool_allowlist.conf GREEN rows |
| automation cron jobs | 11 | cron.reg rows |
| coordination journal | 22434 bytes | knowledge/status/ws_sync.jrnl · liveness view: /standup |
| lane | R responsible | A accountable | C consulted | I informed | status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| vault-suite | family-suite vault/c… | R=warden+media-m… | A=pm | C=librarian+auth… | I=operator |
| recombine | researcher | pm | architect | all | active |
| acl | engineer | pm | referee | operator | active |
| livingdocs | librarian | pm | researcher | team | active |
| day0 | team | operator | pm | all | active |
| auto | conductor | pm | engineer | team | active |
| model | modelwright | pm | engineer-gpu | team | active |
| gpu | engineer-gpu | pm | modelwright | team | active |
| os | engineer-os | architect | warden | team | active |
| compiler | engineer-compiler | pm | referee | team | active |
| silicon | engineer-silicon | pm | operator | team | active |
| browser | engineer-browser | pm | racing | team | active |
| cleanserve | engineer-browser | pm | researcher | team | active |
| swarm | engineer-swarm | pm | conductor | team | active |
| video | engineer-video | pm | architect | researcher | active |
| atlas | architect | pm | librarian | team | active |
| atlashyg-gate | referee | architect | pm | operator | LIVE |
| atlashyg-prov | warden | architect | referee | operator | LIVE |
| atlashyg-dedup | librarian | architect | pm | operator | LIVE |
| atlashyg-contra | referee | architect | researcher | operator | LIVE |
| atlashyg | librarian | architect | referee | warden | active |
| atlashyg-budget | pm | architect | conductor | operator | LIVE |
| atlashyg-safety | warden | architect | referee | operator | LIVE |
| atlashyg-cite | researcher | architect | librarian | operator | PARTIAL |
| atlashyg-semdedup | librarian | architect | modelwright | operator | DESIGN |
| recall | librarian | pm | modelwright | researcher | active |
| atlashyg-ontmerge | architect | architect | researcher | operator | DESIGN |
| atlashyg-selfclean | conductor | architect | warden | operator | DESIGN |
| research | researcher | pm | librarian | team | active |
| coe | librarian | pm | warden | referee | active |
| eff | census | pm | conductor | researcher | active |
| pmdash | pm | pm | fin | librarian | active |
| value | fin | pm | hr | operator | active |
| dmkt | researcher | pm | engineer | fin | active |
| office | counsel | pm | fin | librarian | active |
| sovgit | engineer | pm | conductor | team | active |
| graphics | engineer-graphics | pm | engineer-gpu | team | active |
| plane | janitor | warden | engineer | team | active |
| experiential | racing | pm | librarian | team | active |
| Gx-graphics | graphics-game-SOTA-r… | engineer-graphic… | pm | architect+refere… | operator+all… |
R=responsible A=accountable C=consulted I=informed · source knowledge/store/raci- (40 lanes; A=operator = the executive owns the portfolio)
| total | open | gating (sev≥6) | third-party |
|---|---|---|---|
| 145 | 110 | 45 | 8 |
third-party = rows whose note names stock git / gitea / DSM nginx / Synology / vendor surfaces (declared heuristic). The work-refusing gate lives in nx_ws_cycle: no WORK action while an in-scope debt ≥ sev-floor is open.
| sev | top gating debts (sev ≥ 7) |
|---|---|
| 8 | DRY verdict lib nx_gate_verdict SHIPPED 07-18 (emit contract matches the nx_gate_green judge); 2 exemplars migrated GREEN (store_put/plan_ru… |
| 7 | WMS write lane unlocked = race debt; claims/lease it |
| 7 | DSM nginx co-squats 443; /mcp intermittent = availability gap |
| 7 | nx_evidence_checkin LOADED GUN: allowlist pins root=runtime/ (7-file skeleton) but saves to canonical ecograph_full - one cap-holder call co… |
| 23 | REPRODUCED 2026-07-18: /api/promote target=nx_store_put returned PROMOTED 2x + /api/build BUILT 142141B (has putn) yet the LIVE NAS tool elf… |
| 7 | pmdash(F320-324)+eff(F730-736)+value(F301-303)+this-session ROI-v0 = 4 overlapping ROI/oversight planes; CONVERGE to ONE honest-oversight sp… |
Composed from the sibling-owned knowledge/store/roi- plane (the convergence surface). Honors the plane ROI-CONVERGE rule: only the CONSERVATIVE FLOOR is summed; 1 SUPERSEDED + all COORD rows are EXCLUDED by construction. A modeled SaaS/energy/time avoidance estimate — not revenue, not a measurement; aspirational ceilings are never summed here.
| id | replaces / avoids | axis | qty | rate/mo | subtotal/mo | basis |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| r01 | wiki + dev-portal (livingdocs) vs Confluence/Notion | saas | 1 | $10.00 | $10.00 | Confluence/Notion-class wiki+dev-portal ~$10/seat/mo published 2026, 1 seat |
| r02 | CRM vs Salesforce/HubSpot | saas | 1 | $25.00 | $25.00 | Salesforce Starter ~$25/seat/mo published 2026 |
| r03 | deploy + hosting vs Vercel | saas | 1 | $20.00 | $20.00 | Vercel Pro ~$20/mo published 2026 |
| r04 | containers vs Docker | saas | 1 | $9.00 | $9.00 | Docker Pro ~$9/mo published 2026 |
| r05 | search + deep-research vs Perplexity | saas | 1 | $20.00 | $20.00 | Perplexity Pro ~$20/mo published 2026 |
| r06 | office vs Microsoft 365 | saas | 1 | $6.00 | $6.00 | M365 Business Basic ~$6/seat/mo published 2026 |
| r07 | mail + sending vs Google Workspace | saas | 1 | $6.00 | $6.00 | Workspace Starter ~$6/seat/mo published 2026 |
| r08 | project mgmt vs Asana | saas | 1 | $11.00 | $11.00 | Asana Starter ~$11/seat/mo published 2026 |
| r09 | supervision + monitoring vs Datadog | saas | 1 | $15.00 | $15.00 | Datadog-class host monitoring ~$15/host/mo published 2026 |
| r10 | workflow automation vs Zapier | saas | 1 | $20.00 | $20.00 | Zapier Starter ~$20/mo published 2026 |
| r11 | comms vs Slack | saas | 1 | $7.00 | $7.00 | Slack Pro ~$7/seat/mo published 2026 |
| r12 | authz/identity vs Auth0 | saas | 1 | $10.00 | $10.00 | Auth0/identity dev tier ~$10/mo published 2026 (conservative) |
| r20 | own-hardware energy vs cloud VMs (net) | energy | 1 | $9.00 | $9.00 | ROUGH: ~$12/mo equivalent always-on small cloud VM minus ~$3/mo owned NAS marginal energy = ~$9/mo net; refine via nx_energy_probe (measured… |
| r30 | autonomy dividend (zero-Claude loop) | time | 1 | $50.00 | $50.00 | FLOOR: ~70pct of loop tasks run zero-Claude (/compare/autograde); ~10 hrs/mo avoided x placeholder $5/hr floor (real dev time worth far more… |
| roi-effcost | COST-ANCHOR (eff lane) | measured | 0 | $0.00 | $0.00 | eff lane adds the MISSING measured COST side for ROI-CONVERGE: nx_eff_scan measures tokens/time FROM worklog+transcripts (FACT floor); $ con… |
| TOTAL conservative floor / month | $218.00 | modeled avoidance; 15 value lines; NOT revenue, NOT measured | ||||
| tier | next action |
|---|---|
| order | eat gating debts first → biggest ready rocks → maturity next-rungs (the debt-gate in nx_ws_cycle enforces this; it is not advice) |
| maturity | compiler -- inliner-miscompile-fix-then-aarch64-backend |
| maturity | sites -- multi-site-cms-template-from-config |
| maturity | autonomy -- close-loop-F204-cron-then-F208-feeder-70pct-to-100pct |
| axis | vs Jira Align / Asana Goals / Monday / Power BI-class exec dashboards |
|---|---|
| BEST (measured) | every figure machine-derived from live artifacts (stores/logs/registries) -- zero manual status entry; SOTA tools rely on humans updating fields |
| BEST (measured) | honesty gates: liar-kill on unevidenced claims + two-witness triangulation + fail-closed UNSEEDED ROI -- no SOTA PM dashboard refuses to show a number it cannot ground |
| BEST (measured) | debt-gated flow: the conductor refuses WORK while gating debt is open (mechanized stop-and-eat); SOTA has no equivalent tooth |
| PAR | CPM critical path / float (/frontier) vs MS-Project-class scheduling |
| GAP | resource leveling + capacity + EVM: nishi_project has the organs but its plane is UNSEEDED (gate 9/31 RED) -- honest gap, next rung |
| GAP | probabilistic forecasting (Monte-Carlo when-will-it-be-done), velocity/burn trends over history, telemetry-scored OKRs -- research opportunities below |
| opportunity | fetch targets |
|---|---|
| dx-core-4-unified-devex-metrics (roi- plane) | DX Core 4 (2024, Noda/Storey/Forsgren/Winter, getdx.com): unifies DORA+SPACE+DevEx into 4 dims (speed/effectiveness/quality/business-impact)… |
| probabilistic-schedule-forecasting (roi- plane) | Monte-Carlo throughput forecasting (Vacanti 'When Will It Be Done', Magennis/actionableagile): replace our point-CPM ES/EF (F202 board) with… |
| earned-value-mgmt-ansi-748 (roi- plane) | EVM ANSI/EIA-748 + PMI: SPI/CPI from real cost+schedule = the estimate->measured unlock for our ROI (nishi_project EVM plane is UNSEEDED 9/3… |
| DORA/flow metrics from our own event planes (deploy frequency, lead time -- raw events already in ws_sync.jrnl + promote logs) | DORA 2024-25 State of DevOps; Flow Framework (Kersten); value-stream metrics literature |
| Monte-Carlo schedule forecasting on the frontier DAG (probabilistic ES/EF instead of point CPM) | Vacanti 'When Will It Be Done'; reference-class forecasting (Flyvbjerg); MCMC throughput models |
| evidence-based portfolio ROI (replace declared rates with fetched market comparators, auto-refreshed) | ANSI-748 EVM criteria; lean-portfolio ROI critiques; public SaaS price pages as rate oracles |
| telemetry-scored OKRs (grade objectives from live meters, no self-report) | OpenTelemetry-to-OKR pipelines; Google OKR grading practice |